13 Friday the 13th Plot Holes That Make ZERO Sense (But We Still Love Them)

on

 


The Friday the 13th franchise is iconic—but it’s also notorious for plot holes, continuity issues, and logic-defying twists that only hardcore fans dare defend. Here’s a breakdown of the biggest plot holes that span the saga:

🔊 1. Jason’s Age and Growth (Part 1 vs. Part 2)

  • Plot Hole: In Part 1 (1980), Pamela Voorhees says Jason drowned as a boy in 1957. Yet in Part 2 (1981), a full-grown Jason appears just five years later, living in the woods.

  • Why It’s a Problem: There’s no explanation for how Jason survived drowning, grew up feral, and never contacted his mom—who believed he was dead the whole time.

🧟 2. Jason’s Resurrection and Superhuman Abilities

  • Plot Hole: In Parts 2–4, Jason is mortal. By Part 6 (Jason Lives), he’s undead and superhuman—brought back to life by lightning like Frankenstein.

  • Why It’s a Problem: No one explains when or how he becomes immortal. It’s just... suddenly magic.

🗓️ 3. Timeline Chaos

  • Plot Hole: The timeline from Parts 1–8 is a mess. Characters age inconsistently, and later sequels are set “years later” without aging the world or technology properly.

  • Why It’s a Problem: By Jason Takes Manhattan (Part 8), we should be in the late ‘90s or 2000s, yet it’s still clearly the late ‘80s.

ðŸšĒ 4. Crystal Lake to Manhattan?

  • Plot Hole: In Jason Takes Manhattan, a boat from a small inland lake somehow sails to the Atlantic Ocean and arrives in New York.

  • Why It’s a Problem: Camp Crystal Lake is landlocked. There’s no explanation how this is even geographically possible.

🧎 5. Jason’s Ever-Changing Look

  • Plot Hole: Jason’s body drastically changes from movie to movie—height, build, face, and even clothing—without reason.

  • Why It’s a Problem: There’s no narrative consistency to his physical form. It’s like a new Jason every film.

💀 6. Jason Goes to Hell... and Becomes a Demon Worm?

  • Plot Hole: Jason Goes to Hell (Part 9) introduces a demonic slug/worm thing that jumps bodies. Suddenly Jason has a sister and a niece, and only a blood relative can kill him.

  • Why It’s a Problem: This lore appears out of nowhere, never mentioned before, and is ignored afterward.

ðŸ›ļ 7. Jason X and Space Nonsense

  • Plot Hole: Jason X takes place in 2455, but never explains how Earth 1 became uninhabitable or how Jason was frozen and preserved for centuries.

  • Why It’s a Problem: It's sci-fi madness with no connection to prior films, essentially a self-contained parody with no rules.

🔁 8. Freddy vs. Jason Timeline Problems

  • Plot Hole: Freddy vs. Jason assumes Jason is once again mortal (sort of) and vulnerable to Freddy, despite previously being a supernatural juggernaut.

  • Why It’s a Problem: Neither franchise explains how they coexist or how Jason "sleeps" enough for Freddy to manipulate him.

ðŸŠĶ 9. Jason’s Deaths Never Matter

  • Plot Hole: Jason dies numerous times—machete to the head, drowning, explosion, cryogenic freezing—and always comes back with no explanation.

  • Why It’s a Problem: There’s no consistent resurrection mechanic. Sometimes it's magic, sometimes science, sometimes... nothing.

🎭 10. The Copycat Killer (Part 5)

  • Plot Hole: In Part 5, Jason isn’t the killer—it’s a random ambulance driver in a mask.

  • Why It’s a Problem: Fans hated it, and the film provides no real foreshadowing or logic to the killer’s strength mimicking Jason’s.

🔊 11. Jason Is Selectively Silent... Until He’s Not

  • Problem: Jason is famously mute throughout the franchise, never uttering a word. But in Friday the 13th Part III, he lets out a groan or grunt when he's injured.

  • Plot Hole: Why does he make noises in some movies and stay silent in others? If he's physically capable of making sounds, why go full mime the rest of the time?

🔊 12. Jason’s Fear of Water… Suddenly Becomes Canon

  • Problem: In Freddy vs. Jason, Freddy exploits Jason’s supposed fear of water—something that never existed in any previous film.

  • Plot Hole: Jason has lived in a lake, used water as an ambush point, and walked out of it like a slasher Poseidon for decades. Since when is he hydrophobic?

🔊 13. Jason Regenerates… But Also Needs Medical Attention?

  • Problem: In Jason X, future scientists discover Jason has regenerative tissue that makes him unkillable. But in Part IV, he’s nearly killed by a child with a machete.

  • Plot Hole: If he had healing powers all along, why does he take so much damage in earlier films and stay "dead" for years at a time?

If you’re a fan of horror movies, slashers, and cinematic chaos like this, don’t miss the monthly Nerdthusiast Movie Podcast! We dive into cult classics, new releases, and all the weird, bad, and bloody films you love. 🎃

Listen for FREE on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/52betfhQiRflbCd5vIJsHv




Comments

Post a Comment